EL CONSEJO DE ADMINISTRACIÓN
FORM 6-K
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
Report of Foreign Private Issuer
Pursuant to Rule 13a-16 or 15d-16
of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
For the month of March, 2004
Commission File Number: 001-09531
Telefónica, S.A.
(Translation of registrant’s name into English)
Gran Vía, 28
28013 Madrid, Spain
3491-459-3050
(Address of principal executive offices)
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant files or will file annual reports under cover of Form 20-F or Form 40-F:
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is submitting the Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(1):
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is submitting the Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(7):
Indicate by check mark whether by
furnishing the information contained in this Form, the registrant is also
thereby furnishing the information to the Commission pursuant to Rule 12g3-2(b)
under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934:
If “Yes” is marked, indicate
below the file number assigned to the registrant in connection with Rule
12g3-2(b): N/A
Telefónica, S.A.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Item
|
|
Sequential Page Number
|
|
|
|
1.
|
Annual Report on Corporate Governance- Financial year 2003
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Telefónica S.A., as provided in article 82 of the Spanish Stock Market Act (Ley del Mercado de Valores), hereby reports the following
SIGNIFICANT EVENT
In
order to comply with the requirements of article 116 of the Spanish Stock Market
Act and with Order/3722/2003 of 26 December 2003, the Corporate Governance
Report of Telefónica, S.A. for the year 2003 is attached to this
notification, after having been approved by the Board of Directors of
Telefónica, S.A. The report will be made available to the shareholders on
the company website (www.telefonica.es/www.telefonica.com).
Madrid, 8 March 2004
ANNUAL REPORT
ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
Financial year 2003
- - Index - -
1. INTRODUCTION.
2. SHAREHOLDING STRUCTURE
2.1 SHARE CAPITAL
2.2 SIGNIFICANT SHAREHOLDINGS
2.3 RELATIONS WITH SIGNIFICANT SHAREHOLDERS
2.4 SHAREHOLDINGS OF THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
2.5 EXISTENCE OF SHAREHOLDERS’ AGREEMENTS.
2.6 INFORMATION ON OWN PORTFOLIO
3. STRUCTURE OF THE BOARD
3.1 COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
3.2 RULES OF ORGANISATION AND OPERATION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
3.2.1 Procedure to select, appoint and remove Directors
3.2.2 Operation of the Board of Directors.
3.2.3 The Executive Committee
3.2.4 Board of Directors sub-committees
3.2.4.1 Audit and Control Committee
3.2.4.2 Nominating, Compensation, and Corporate Governance Committee
3.2.4.3 Human Resources and Corporate Reputation Committee
3.2.4.4 Regulation Committee
3.2.4.5 Service Quality and Customer Service Committee
3.2.4.6 International Affairs Committee
3.3 REMUNERATION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEMBERS
3.4 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
3.4.1 Directors appointed in relation to significant shareholders
3.4.2 Members of the Board of Directors of Telefónica with management or executive offices in other companies in the Group
4. INFORMATION ON RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS AND INTRAGROUP OPERATIONS
4.1 OPERATIONS PERFORMED WITH SIGNIFICANT SHAREHOLDERS
4.2 OPERATIONS PERFORMED WITH THE DIRECTORS AND EXECUTIVES OF THE COMPANY AND OF THE GROUP COMPANIES
4.3 SIGNIFICANT OPERATIONS PERFORMED WITH OTHER COMPANIES BELONGING TO THE SAME GROUP
5. INFORMATION ON RISK CONTROL SYSTEMS.
5.1 GENERAL RISK CONTROL MODEL.
5.2 CONTROLS OVER THE FINANCIAL-ACCOUNTING INFORMATION PROCESS
6. RELATIONS WITH SHAREHOLDERS AND MARKETS
6.1 OPERATION OF THE GENERAL SHAREHOLDERS’ MEETING.
6.1.1 Existence and description of the Regulations of the General Shareholders’ Meeting
6.1.2 Rights of the shareholders in relation to the General Shareholders’ Meeting
6.1.3 Attendance data from previous Meetings
6.1.4 List of the resolutions passed by the General Shareholders’ Meeting
6.2 TRANSPARENCY AND DISCLOSURE.
6.2.1 Shareholders’ Office
6.2.2 Investor Relations Department
6.2.3 Market disclosure
6.2.4 Information on the web page
7. DEGREE OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE RECOMMENDATIONS.
7.1 TELEFÓNICA, S.A.
7.2 OTHER COMPANIES IN THE TELEFÓNICA GROUP
1
INTRODUCTION
The
Annual Report on Corporate Governance of Telefónica, S.A. (hereinafter
“Telefónica” or the “Company”) for financial year
2003, approved by its Board of Directors, at its meeting held on 25th February
2004, after the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee
report, aims to provide a detailed explanation of the structures of the
corporate governance system of Telefónica and its practical operation to
inform its shareholders and investors.
The
Board of Directors provides the shareholders this Report, in fulfilment of the
obligation established under “Act 26/2003, of 17th July, that amends Act
24/1988, of 28th July on the Stock Exchange, and the reviewed text of the
Spanish Companies Act, approved by Royal Decree 1564/1989, of 22nd December, in
order to reinforce the transparency of the Spanish listed companies”
(Transparency Act). In any case, one must point out that the Company already
published a first Report on Corporate Governance relating to financial year
2002, prior to this report legally required.
In
preparing this Report, the provisions of said Act 26/2003 have been complied
with, as well as the provisions complementing such Actin “Order/3722/2003,
of 26th December, on the annual report on corporate governance and other
information instruments for listed companies and other firms”. Moreover,
information has been included on other matters that may be of interest to
shareholders and investors, such as that on the work carried out by the Board of
Directors and its Sub-committees during financial year 2003, or that related to
the channels of information between the Company and the market. One must point
out that all the data contained in this Report refers to the financial year
ended on 31st December 2003, except in the matters for which another specific
date of reference is provided.
This Report also states the degree
of implementation of Corporate Governance practices in other listed companies
within the Telefónica Group. In this sense, one must point out that this
Group has a total of 21 listed companies of six different nationalities and
Telefónica has been the driving force to ensure all these companies
fulfil minimum standards of common corporate governance, regardless of their
nationality and the markets they are listed on, just as detailed in section 7.2
of this Report. On the other hand, the three Spanish listed companies in the
Group have prepared their respective Reports on Corporate Governance to an
identical structure to this Report, in order to provide the shareholders
homogeneous information in the matter, respecting, in all cases, the autonomy of
decision of their respective governing and executive bodies.
The
fundamental principles of Telefónica’s corporate governance are set
forth in its Articles of Association and the Regulations of its Board of
Directors. Both documents are available to the shareholders and investors at the
Company registered office and on its web page.
2
SHAREHOLDING STRUCTURE
2.1 SHARE CAPITAL.
On
the date of this Report, the share capital of Telefónica, subscribed and
fully paid up, amounted to 4,955,891,361 euros, and it is divided into
4,955,891,361 shares of one euro face value each.
All the Telefónica shares
are ordinary, of a sole series, and are represented by account entries.
The
shares are fully subscribed and paid up and grant the same rights and
obligations to all shareholders. Telefónica shareholders do not have any
accessory rights whatsoever. Likewise, the Articles of Association of
Telefónica contain no provision on privileges, special powers or rights
arising from the holding of shares. Moreover, there are no statutory articles
that impose any restriction or limitation on the free transfer of the
Telefónica’s
shares.
Regardless of this, by
virtue of what is set forth in “Act 5/1995, of 23rd March, on the legal
regime for the disposal of state shareholdings in certain companies”,
the Council of Ministers approved “Royal Decree 8/1997, of 10th January,
an Application of the Regime of Prior Administrative Authorisation for
Telefónica and other companies in its Group” in which it
established the need to request administrative authorisation prior to
Telefónica adopting certain resolutions, especially relevant ones, once
the State shareholding had totally disappeared. Acquisition of shares in
Telefónica was also subject to the regime of prior administrative
authorisation when giving rise to disposal of at least 10 per cent of the
relevant stock capital.
After
amendment of “Act 5/1995, of 23rd March on the legal regime of disposal of
state shareholdings in certain companies” introduced by “Act 6/2003,
of 30th December (Accompanying Act)”, there is now, in force as of 18th
February 2007, a regime of administrative intervention (need for notification
and power of veto by the Spanish State) in relation to acts of disposal of
shares of Telefónica that represent at least 10 per cent of its share
capital.
Lastly,
and pursuant to the terms set forth in the Company’s Articles of
Association, no shareholder may cast a number of votes exceeding 10 per cent of
the total Company’s share capital with the right to vote existing at each
moment, regardless of the number of the shares held. When determining the
maximum number of votes each shareholder may cast, only the shares each one is
holder of shall be calculated, not including those of other holders who have
delegated representation on the
former.
The limitation established
in the preceding paragraph shall also be applicable to the maximum number of
votes that maybe cast – jointly or separately – by two or more
shareholder companies belonging to a same group of companies, as well as the
maximum number of votes that may be cast by a shareholding individual or
corporation and the entity or entities that control these directly or indirectly
control these.
Considering the
total stock capital of Telefónica, and in relation to its present
shareholding structure, that limit to the number votes established in its
Articles of Association lacks application in practice, as at present there is no
shareholder with a direct or indirect shareholding exceeding 6 per cent of the
share capital.
2.2 SIGNIFICANT SHAREHOLDINGS.
To
the extent that the Telefónica shares are represented by account entries,
there thus being no record of shareholders kept by the Company itself, it is not
possible to precisely ascertain its shareholding structure.
In any case, according to the
existing information at the Company, one may say that there is no individual or
corporation that directly or indirectly, alone or jointly, exercises, or may
exercise control over Telefónica, on the terms established in article 4
of the Securities Markets Act.
There are, however, certain
shareholders who hold stakes that may be considered significant, in the sense of
Ministerial Order 3722/2003, of 26th December, who are as
follows:
|
Total
|
Direct stake
|
Indirect stake
|
Percentage
|
Shares
|
Percentage
|
Shares
|
Percentage
|
Shares
|
BBVA (*)
|
6.09%
|
301,813,784
|
1.81%
|
89,701,634
|
4.28%
|
212,112.150
|
“La Caixa” (**)
|
3.5%
|
173,456,198
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
(*)
According to the information provided by the Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria,
S.A. (hereinafter, BBVA) in its Annual Accounts on 31st December 2003. As the
bank states in that document, the stake held with the criteria of continued
shareholding in the capital of is
5.17%.
(**)
According to the data provided by the Caja de Ahorros y Pensiones de Barcelona,
“La Caixa” (hereinafter, La Caixa) on its Web Page, with information
updated to 31st December 2003.
According
to the information available to the Company, during financial year 2003, there
were no significant changes in its capital structure.
In
relation to these significant shareholders, the persons identified in chapter
III of this Report have been proposed as members of the Board of Directors.
In
addition to these significant stakes held on stable terms, according to the
notification issued to the National Stock Exchange Commission on 8th January
2003, the financial institution Chase Manhattan Nominees Ltd., held a stake of
6.80% in the stock capital of Telefónica, as depository entity, so that
stake is held in name and on behalf of its customers.
Moreover, on 6th February 2004,
the financial institution Citibank, NA held 242,688,336 shares in
Telefónica that represented 4.9% of its stock capital, according to the
internal reports prepared by the Company itself. That stake is held as
established in the Depository Agreement granted between the Company and Citibank
NA, in name and on behalf of the holders of ADRs, for the purposes of issue and
trading of those societies on the New York Stock Exchange and the Stock Exchange
of Lima. According to the terms of that agreement, Citibank N.A. is obliged to
exercise the political and economic rights it holds according to the
instructions it is sent by the holders of ADRs, on the terms and conditions
established in the depository agreement.
According to the information
obtained from “Sociedad de Gestión de los Sistemas de Registro,
Compensación y Liquidación de Valores” (Securities,
Recording, Clearing and Settlement Systems Management Company) (Iberclear),
dated April 2003[1],
the number of shareholders of Telefónica, according to individualised
records in favour of individuals and corporations, amounted to approximately
1,693,049 shareholders.
2.3 RELATIONS WITH SIGNIFICANT SHAREHOLDERS.
The
Company maintains ordinary commercial relations with both significant
shareholders, in relation to which detailed information is provided in section
4.1 of this Report. These operations are performed under market conditions,
subject to the requisites concerning transactions with significant shareholders
established in the Regulations of the Board of Directors.
As to the corporate relations
there may be with these shareholders, it is pointed out, in relation to BBVA,
that Telefónica, through its subsidiary Telefónica de
España, S.A.U., is the holder of 36,215,223 shares in BBVA, which
represents 1.13% of its stock capital.
On the other hand, the following
table details the companies in which Telefónica and BBVA hold joint
stakes:
Company
|
Stake held by Telefónica
|
Stake held by BBVA
|
Activity
|
SPAIN
|
Adquira España, S.A.
|
40%(1)
|
40%(2)
|
Providing
telecommunications, internet and e-commerce services.
|
Azeler Automoción, S.A.
|
50%(3)
|
50%(4)
|
Automotive portal.
|
Hispasat, S.A.
|
13,23%
|
10,75%(5)
|
Operating satellite communications system.
|
Iniciativas Residenciales en Internet, S.A.
|
50%(3)
|
50%(2)
|
Real estate portal.
|
Mobipay España, S.A.
|
13,3%(6)
|
8%(2)
|
Development of means of payment by mobile telephony.
|
Mobipay International, S.A.
|
36%(7)
|
27,5%(2)
|
Development of means of payment by mobile telephony.
|
On line services for multiple users, S.A. (SOLIUM)
|
33,3%(8)
|
33,3%(2)
|
Providing technological services such as Internet support and operations.
|
Telefónica Factoring E.F.C., S.A.
|
50%
|
30%
|
Providing factoring services for the suppliers in the Telefónica Group.
|
Uno-e Bank, S.A.
|
33%(3)
|
67%(9)
|
Providing Internet banking services.
|
BRAZIL
|
Telefónica Factoring Brasil, S.L.
|
59,98
|
10,24%(10)
|
Providing factoring services for suppliers in the Telefónica Group.
|
COLOMBIA
|
Telefónica Data Colombia, S.A.
|
65%(11)
|
35%(12)
|
Providing telecommunications services.
|
MEXICO
|
Adquira México S.A. de C.V.
|
50%(13)
|
50%(14)
|
Providing solutions to optimise the purchase and sale of goods and services between companies.
|
OTHER COMPANIES
|
Atento, N.V.
|
91,35%
|
8,65%(15)
|
Providing telemarketing services.
|
(1) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Telefónica de España, S.A.U. (20%)
and Telefónica Publicidad e Información, S.A. (20%).
(2) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Banco Bilbao Vizcaya E-Commerce, S.A.
(3) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Terra Networks, S.A.
(4) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Banco Bilbao Vizcaya E-Commerce, S.A. (25%) and
Finanzia Banco de Crédito Local, S.A.(25%).
(5) Stake
held through its subsidiary, BBVA Factoring, S.A.
(6) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Telefónica Móviles España,
S.A.U.
(7) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Telefónica Móviles, S.A.
(8) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Telefónica Data España, S.A.U.
(9) Stake
held through its subsidiaries, Banco Bilbao Vizcaya E-Commerce, S.A. (51%) and
Finanzia Banco de Crédito Local, S.A. (16%).
(10) Stake
held through its subsidiary, BBVA Factoring, S.A.
(11) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Telefónica DataCorp, S.A.U.
(12) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Cidessa Uno, S.L. (100% owned).
(13) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Katalyx Inc.
(14) Stake
held through its subsidiary, Visacom, S.A. de C.V.
(15) Stake
held through its subsidiary, General de Participaciones Empresariales,
S.L.
Moreover,
as to La Caixa, Telefónica Soluciones Sectoriales, S.A.U. (a subsidiary
of Telefónica de España, S.A.U.) holds 6.92% of the stock capital
of Barcelona Empren, S.A., in which the BBVA and La Caixa each hold 6.92%.
Likewise, that same subsidiary of the Telefónica Group holds a 5% in the
company Foment de Ciutat Vella, S.A., in which BBVA holds 10% and La Caixa
12.5%.
Lastly, as to the possible
existence of crossed or linked Directors, it must be mentioned, in relation to
Telefónica, that Telefónica de España, S.A.U. was appointed
a member of the Board of Directors of BBVA. At present, Mr Angel Vilá
Boix represents that corporation on the Board of Directors of the company.
2.4 SHAREHOLDINGS OF THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
According
to the data available to the Company, the total number of shares in
Telefónica held individually by the present Directors of the company,
directly or indirectly, on the date of this Report, amount to 747,763 shares
(0.015% of the stock capital):
Name
|
Directly
held
|
Indirectly
held
|
Number
of shares held
|
Mr
César Alierta Izuel
|
481,397
|
---
|
481,397
|
Mr
Isidro Fainé Casas (1)
|
7,164
|
---
|
7,164
|
Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero (2)
|
115
|
---
|
115
|
Mr
Fernando de Almansa Moreno-Barreda
|
2,112
|
---
|
2,112
|
Mr Jesús María Cadenato Matía (2)
|
9,906
|
---
|
9,906
|
Mr
Maximino Carpio García
|
5,836
|
---
|
5,836
|
Mr
Carlos Colomer Casellas
|
543
|
---
|
543
|
Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero
|
1,811
|
99,500(4)
|
101,311
|
Mr
José Fonollosa García (2)
|
---
|
---
|
---
|
Mr
Gonzalo Hinojosa Fernández de Angulo
|
37,958
|
---
|
37,958
|
Mr
Miguel Horta e Costa
|
354
|
---
|
354
|
Mr
Pablo Isla Alvarez de Tejera
|
386
|
---
|
386
|
Mr
Luis Lada Díaz
|
30,000
|
---
|
30,000
|
Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla (1)
|
2,106
|
642
(3)
|
2,748
|
Mr
Enrique Used Aznar
|
19,450
|
17,988
(4)
|
37,438
|
Mr
Mario E. Vázquez
|
10
|
---
|
10
|
Mr
Antonio Viana−Baptista
|
21,994
|
---
|
21,994
|
Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga (2)
|
53
|
---
|
53
|
Mr
Antonio Alonso Ureba
|
8,438
|
---
|
8,438
|
TOTAL
|
629,633
|
118,130
|
747,763
|
(1)
Appointed at the proposal of La Caixa.
(2)
Appointed at the proposal of BBVA.
(3)
Stake held through relatives in the first degree.
(4)
Stake held through two controlled companies, one 60% and the other 100%.
2.5. EXISTENCE OF SHAREHOLDERS’ AGREEMENTS.
Telefónica
has received no notifications whatsoever of the existence of agreements between
its shareholders.
2.6. INFORMATION ON OWN PORTFOLIO.
On
31st December 2002, Telefónica had a total of 91,631,076 own shares, that
represented 1,88516% of the stock capital of the Company.
During
financial year 2003, and in fulfilment of the obligation to notify acquisition
of own shares, Telefónica, on 22nd October 2003, notified the CNMV, the
accumulated acquisition of a total 50,372,028 own shares (gross purchases) that
represented 1.016% of the existing share capital on the date of that
communication. On that date, the position of the net own portfolio of the
Company was 30,051,447 shares, that represented 0.606% of their share capital.
Lastly, one must state that, on
31st December 2003, Telefónica had a total of 41,732,869 own shares, that
represented 0.842 % of the stock capital of the Company.
3
STRUCTURE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
The
rules of organisation and operation of the Company’s Board of Directors,
and its Sub-committees are set forth in the Company’s Articles of
Association and in the Regulations of its Board of Directors. Both documents
are available to all the shareholders and investors, at the registered office of
the Company and on its web page.
3.1 COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS .
Telefónica’s
Articles of Association foresee that the Board of Directors shall be comprised
of a minimum of five and a maximum of twenty members, who shall be appointed by
the General Shareholders’ Meeting. Provisionally, according to the
provisions contained in the Spanish Companies Act and in the Articles of
Association, the Board of Directors may cover existing vacancies by co-option.
Telefónica’s
Board of Directors is now comprised of nineteen Directors, a number that is
considered adequate to ensure effective operation, considering the complexity of
the Group the company heads, the significant number of companies that comprise
it, the variety of sectors in which it carries out its activity, its
multinational nature, as well as its economic and corporate relevance.
As
of the date of this Report, the Board of Directors of Telefónica is
comprised of the following persons:
Name
|
Post
|
Type
of director
|
Date
of first appointment
|
Date
of last appointment
|
Mr
César Alierta Izuel
|
Chairman
(1)
|
Executive
|
29-01-1997(8)
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Isidro Fainé Casas
|
Vice-Chairman
|
Proprietary(6)
|
26-01-1994(8)
|
15-06-2001
|
Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero
|
Vice-Chairman
|
Proprietary(7)
|
12-04-2002(8)
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Fernando de Almansa Moreno-Barreda
|
Director
|
Independent
|
26-02-2003(8)
|
11-04-2003
|
Mr
Jesús María Cadenato Matía
|
Director
|
Proprietary(7)
|
11-04-2003
|
11-04-2003
|
Mr
Maximino Carpio García
|
Director
|
Independent
|
29-01-1997(8)
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Carlos Colomer Casellas
|
Director
|
Independent
|
28-03-2001(8)
|
15-06-2001
|
Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero
|
Director
|
Independent
|
28-03-2001(8)
|
15-06-2001
|
Mr
José Fonollosa García
|
Director
|
Proprietary(7)
|
11-04-2003
|
11-04-2003
|
Mr
Gonzalo Hinojosa Fernández de Angulo
|
Director
|
Independent
|
12-04-2002
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Miguel Horta e Costa
|
Director
|
Independent
|
17-03-1998
|
11-04-2003
|
Mr
Pablo Isla Alvarez de Tejera
|
Director
|
Independent
|
12-04-2002
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Luis Lada Díaz
|
Director(2)
|
Executive
|
10-08-2000(8)
|
15-06-2001
|
Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla
|
Director
|
Proprietary
(6)
|
21-04-1995
|
15-06-2001
|
Mr
Enrique Used Aznar
|
Director
|
Independent
|
12-04-2002
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Mario E. Vázquez
|
Director(3)
|
Executive
|
20-12-2000(8)
|
15-06-2001
|
Mr
Antonio Viana−Baptista
|
Director(4)
|
Executive
|
12-01-2000(8)
|
04-02-2000
|
Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga
|
Director
|
Proprietary
(7)
|
27-02-2002(8)
|
12-04-2002
|
Mr
Antonio Alonso Ureba
|
Director-Secretary(5)
|
Executive
|
28-03-2001(8)
|
15-06-2001
|
(1) Executive
Chairman of the Company.
(2) General
Manager of Development, Planning and Regulation at Telefónica.
(3) Executive
Chairman of Telefónica de Argentina, S.A
(4) Executive
Chairman of Telefónica Móviles, S.A.
(5) Secretary
General of Telefónica.
(6) Appointed
at the proposal of La Caixa.
(7) Appointed
at the proposal of BBVA.
(8) Appointed
by the pre-emptive procedure, that appointment being confirmed at the General
Shareholders’ Meeting immediately following.
On
the other hand, as of the date of this Report, the positions held by the
Directors on the Board sub-committees are specified in the following table:
Directors
|
Executive
Committee
|
Audit
|
Appointment
|
Human
Resources
|
Regulation
|
Quality
|
Internat.
Affairs
|
Mr
César Alierta Izuel
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Isidro Fainé Casas
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero
|
|
X
|
|
|
X
|
|
|
Mr
Fernando de Almansa Moreno-Barreda
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
X
|
Mr
Jesús María Cadenato Matía
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Maximino Carpio García
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Carlos Colomer Casellas
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
X
|
|
Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
X
|
Mr
José Fonollosa García
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Gonzalo Hinojosa Fernández de Angulo
|
|
X
|
|
|
|
X
|
|
Mr
Miguel Horta e Costa
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Pablo Isla Alvarez de Tejera
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
|
Mr
Luis Lada Díaz
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
X
|
Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla
|
|
X
|
|
X
|
|
X
|
|
Mr
Enrique Used Aznar
|
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
|
X
|
Mr
Mario E. Vázquez
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Antonio Viana−Baptista
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga
|
X
|
|
X
|
|
|
|
X
|
Mr
Antonio Alonso Ureba
|
X
|
|
|
|
X
|
|
|
As
to the status of the Directors, the composition of the Board of Directors of
Telefónica fully complies with the recommendations in matters of
corporate governance, as it includes a significant number of independent
Directors (eight) and external Directors (proprietary and independent) forming
an wide majority over the executive ones (fourteen to five). Lastly, the
independent Directors are in majority in relation to the proprietary ones (eight
to six).
The Regulations of the
Board of Directors cover the main rights and obligations of the members of the
Board, especially those arising from the fundamental duties of diligence and
loyalty.
3.2 RULES OF ORGANISATION AND OPERATION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
3.2.1 Procedures for selection, appointment and removal of Directors.
The
main principles of organisation and operation of the Board of Directors are set
forth in the Articles of Association and Regulations of the actual Board,
approved on 29th January 1997 and amended on 22nd July 1998, which is available
for consultation at the registered office of the Company and on its web page.
Those Regulations also regulate the organisation and operation of the Executive
Committee and the Board sub-committees.
As
already mentioned, according to the Articles of Association, the Board of
Directors will be comprised of a minimum of five and a maximum of twenty
members.
The
proposals for appointment of Directors must be preceded by a favourable report
by the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee, which shall
not be binding.
In
this sense, one must point out that the appointment of Directors at
Telefónica is subject, as a general rule, to the decision of the General
Shareholders’ Meeting. Only on certain occasions when it is indispensable
due to vacancies arising since the last General Shareholders’ Meeting, may
it proceed, as established in the Spanish Companies Act, to appointment by
co-option, with a prior report by the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate
Governance Committee, that decision being ratified, in all cases, by the first
General Shareholders’ Meeting held thereafter.
The
only appointment by co-option performed during financial year 2003 was submitted
by the Board of Directors for ratification to the General Shareholders’
Meeting and was granted a favourable report by the Nominating, Compensation and
Corporate Governance Committee. That appointment was ratified by the Ordinary
General Shareholders’ Meeting held on 11th April 2003 that also approved
appointment of another two members of the Board.
The
appointment of external or non-executive Directors must be assigned to persons
of recognised solvency, competency and professional experience, who are willing
to dedicate a sufficient amount of their time to the Company, being extremely
thorough in relation to the selection of the persons called to cover an
independent Director position.
As
to the appointment of independent Directors, the Regulations of the Board of
Directors establishes that it may not propose or appoint to cover an independent
Director position any person who has, or who has had a stable relation of
certain relevance with the management of the Company, or who are linked for
family, professional or commercial reasons to any of the executive Directors or
other top management of the Company, and must also lack stable relations with
the proprietary Directors and with the entities or corporate groups represented
by them.
The
Directors
are appointed for a period of five (5) years and may be re-elected one or more
times for equal times of maximum duration, and must submit their letter of
resignation to the Board of Directors when they reach the age of seventy (70)
years. The executive Directors shall cease to hold office when they reach the
age of sixty five (65), although they may continue to be Directors if so decided
by the Board itself.
Besides, the Directors must hand in their resignation to the Board of Directors
and formalise the relevant resignation: (i) when they cease to hold the
executive post linked to their appointment as Director, or when the reasons for
which they were appointed disappear, (ii) when they incur in any legally
foreseen causes of incompatibility or prohibition, (iii) when they receive a
severe admonition by the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance
Committee due to having failed to fulfil any of their obligations as Directors,
or (iv) when their remaining on the Board may affect the credibility or
reputation the Company has on the markets, or put its interests at risk in any
other way.
3.2.2 Operation of the Board of Directors.
The
Board of Directors is the supervisory and controlling body of the
Company’s activity and exercises specific responsibilities in relation to
the strategy and direction of the business and co-ordination of its Group of
companies, entrusting ordinary management of its business to the executive
bodies and management team.
The
Articles of Association and Regulations of the Board of Directors foresee that
the Board of Directors shall hold its ordinary meeting once a month and, at the
initiative of the Chairman, as often as deemed appropriate for proper running of
the Company. According to this, the Board of Directors sets an annual calendar
of ordinary meetings. During financial year 2003, the Board of Directors of
Telefónica held 13 meetings – 11 of them ordinary and two
extraordinary – of approximately four hours duration each.
As
established in the Regulations of the Board, and except in cases in which
another quorum has specifically been set, the resolutions shall be adopted by
the majority of the Directors appearing at the meeting, present or represented.
In
order to guarantee adequate preparation of the sessions and in order for the
members of the Board to have all the necessary information, the sessions have a
pre-established Agenda, which is notified at least three days before the date
set for the meeting to be held, along with the calling of the session. To that
same end, the Directors are sent the documentation related to the Agenda
sufficiently in advance, it being completed with the documentation and written
presentations that are provided when holding the meeting.
To
provide the necessary information and clarifications in relation to some of the
matters dealt with, practically all the meetings of the Board held in 2003 were
attended by the main executives of the Group, to matters within their remit.
In
order to provide information on the activity carried out by this body during
financial year 2003, it is pointed out that the Board of Directors of
Telefónica has known, debated or taken the relevant decisions on the
matters within its competence, among which the following must be emphasised as
the most outstanding:
(a) In
relation to the Company’s finances:
§ Results:
On a monthly
basis, a detailed presentation has been made to the Board summarising the
consolidated results of the Telefónica Group and its main Lines of
Activity.
§ Periodic
financial information:
The Board
has been presented financial information on each quarter, or in each semester,
on financial year 2003, prior to its presentation to the Markets and their
regulatory Bodies.
§ Economic
information on Latin
America:
Given the importance to the Telefónica Group of its interests in Latin
America, the Board has periodically monitored the economic situation, as well as
the evolution of the business in the countries in that Region in which the Group
is present.
§ Other
matters of a financial
nature: The
passing of resolutions on financial matters by the Board has always been
preceded by the Directors being provided all the relevant information. Thus,
during financial year 2003, the following operations, among others, have been
considered: issues of bonds by Telefónica Europe, B.V., scheme to issue
corporate promissory notes, re-structuring of debt at Telefónica
Argentina, S.A., etc.
(b) In
relation to the business of the Group :
§ Strategic
aspects and objectives:
The Board
has deliberated and adopted decisions on strategic aspects and objectives of the
Group overall, and of its main Lines of Activity.
§ Monitoring
the
activity:
Apart from monitoring the activity and controlling management of the Group
business, which is performed monthly when the Board is provided the preview of
the consolidated results and the results of each Line of Activity (the agenda of
each meeting contains a point titled “Management Report”), on
several occasions throughout financial year 2003 have been subject to a
monographic examination of the situation and the objectives and strategies of
the diverse business in the Group, with intervention before the actual Group by
the top executives of each Line of Activity.
§ Regulatory
aspects: The
Board has been periodically informed and over the last financial year has amply
debated the main regulatory matters that affect the telecommunications Operators
in the Group. Considering that, during financial year 2003, a new General
Telecommunications Act was published in Spain, this new regulatory framework has
been analysed in special detail – especially as to fixed telephony -.
Consideration has also been given, on diverse occasions, to the regulatory
aspects of the diverse telecommunications businesses in Latin America.
(c) In
relation to the structure and organisation of the Company:
§ Organisational
Structure:
The Board,
following examination and a report by the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate
Governance Committee, has considered matters during that financial year related
to the organisational structure of the Company and its Group, and has passed
major resolutions on restructuring and design of the organisation in the months
of September and December 2003.
§ Directors
and Top
Management:
The Board, following a report by the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate
Governance Committee, passed 15 resolutions during financial year 2003 on
appointment of Directors and Top Management.
(d) In
relation to the internal control systems and other matters:
§ Company’s
market disclosure policy..
In addition
to the Board having disclosed specific market decisions or operations, at its
meeting on 26th March 2003, the Board of Directors approved the Disclosure
Controls and procedures Regulation that regulates the processes of
communication, both of specific and periodic information, establishing the
general principles that must be respected by the Company in its
communications.
§ Operations
with Significant
Shareholders:
The Board of Directors, following a report by the Nominating, Compensation and
Corporate Governance Committee, has considered and approved, as appropriate,
transactions with the holders of significant stakes in the Company, in order to
fulfil the terms established in the Regulations of the Board of Directors.
Moreover,
during financial year 2003, after the appropriate analyses and reports, the
Board approved diverse important operations and transactions, among which the
following may be emphasised as most relevant:
§ Strategic
alliance between Telefónica and Terra
Lycos to
replace the strategic resolution of 16th May 2000, to which the company
Bertelsmann A.G. was a party. Moreover, Telefónica, Terra Networks,
S.A., Lycos Inc, and Bertelsmann A.G. signed a preferential interest agreement
that will continue to allow them to explore opportunities of mutually providing
communication services, developments and contents to the “on line”
market.
§ Integration
of the digital satellite television
platforms,
Vía Digital and Canal Satélite Digital, through an agreement
between Telefónica de Contenidos, S.A.U., a subsidiary of
Telefónica, and Sogecable, S.A.
§ Formulation
by Telefónica of a
Take-over
to Acquire all the shares of Terra Networks,
S.A. listed
on the Spanish securities trading system and the NASDAQ of the United States.
§ Process
of divestment by Telefónica in relation to its shareholding in Antena 3
de Televisión,
S.A, a
process that was mandatory to fulfil the terms established in the regulatory
laws on private television then in force. That process of divestment was
structured through two operations both approved by the Board of Directors of
Telefónica. On one hand, the Board of Directors resolved to propose to
the Ordinary General Shareholders’ Meeting, held on 11th April 2003,
distribution of the Premium Reserve for the Issuance of Shares, by delivery to
the Telefónica’s shareholders of shares representing 30% of the
Antena 3 share capital; and, on the other hand, at its meeting on 30th April
2003, the Board agreed to accept the offer presented by the Planeta Group for
25.1% of the Antena 3 de Televisión , S.A. share capital.
§ Furthermore,
as to the relation between the Board of Directors and its sub-committees, one
must point out – notwithstanding what is detailed in section 3.2 of this
Report concerning the activity by these Sub-committees -, that at each ordinary
monthly meeting of the Board of Directors, the Chairman of those sub-committees
reports to the Board on the activity and main tasks and actions carried out by
these during the period immediately preceding; to which end, the agenda of
practically all the ordinary sessions of the Board includes a point called
“Activities by the Board of Directors sub-committees ”.
3.2.3 The Executive Committee.
The
Board of Directors, as well as subject to the legal provisions in force, has
delegated its powers and attributes, except those that may not be delegated by
law or statute, upon a Executive Committee. That Committee provides the Board of
Directors greater operativity and efficiency in performing its duties, providing
it the necessary support through the work it carries out, especially to the
extent that its composition is smaller than that of the Board and it meets more
frequently than it.
The
relations between both bodies are based on a principle of transparency, so the
Board always has full knowledge of the decisions adopted by this Committee.
Thus, the Board of Directors is informed at each of its meetings of all the
resolutions passed by the Executive Committee, to which end a summary of the
Minutes of the meetings of that Committee are distributed to all the Directors,
also proceeding to ratify those resolutions.
On
the date of this Report, the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors is
formed by the following persons:
Members
|
Date of
appointment
|
|
Mr
César Alierta Izuel, Chairman
|
27 January 1999
|
Mr
Isidro Fainé Casas, Vice-Chairman
|
26 January 1994
|
Mr
Jesús María Cadenato Matía, Spokesman
|
30 April 2003
|
Mr
Maximino Carpio García, Spokesman
|
25 October 2000
|
Mr
Carlos Colomer Casellas, Spokesman
|
28 March 2001
|
Mr
Antonio Viana-Baptista, Spokesman
|
23 February 2000
|
Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga, Spokesman
|
27 February 2002
|
Mr
Antonio Alonso Ureba, Secretary
|
28 March 2001
|
The
rules of operation of this Committee are set forth in the Regulations of the
Board, which govern its composition, operation, and its relation to the Board of
Directors.
Resolutions will be
passed by the majority of the Directors attending, and the Chairman shall cast
the deciding vote. The acting Chairman and Secretary to the Executive Committee
shall be the same persons as hold these offices on the Board of Directors.
The meetings of the Executive
Committee shall be called at least three days before the date foreseen to hold
them (normally, they are sent out on the Friday prior to the Committee meeting,
which takes place on Wednesday), and that calling includes an advance on the
foreseeable Agenda of the meeting.
The
Regulations of the Board foresee that the Committee shall hold its ordinary
meetings every fifteen days, and as often as called by its Chairman. In 2003,
the Executive Committee held 19 meeting, with an average length of 3 hours, most
meetings having the intervention of the main Executives of the Group to explain
matters related to their respective area of competence. No external advisors
have attended the meetings of the Executive Committee.
During
financial year 2003, the Committee has examined, in addition to matters related
to the ordinary management of the Company, matters related to investment and
divestment operations by the Company, and other strategic matters.
3.2.4 Other Committees of the Board of Directors.
The
Board of Directors of Telefónica has the following sub-committees:
§ The
Audit and Control Committee,
§ The
Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee,
§ The
Human Resources and Corporate Reputation Committee,
§ The
Regulation Committee,
§ The
Service Quality and Customer Service Committee, and
§ The
International Affairs Committee.
3.2.4.1 Audit and Control Committee.
As
of the date of this Report, this Committee is formed by the following
members:
Members
|
Date of
appointment
|
|
Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla, Chairman
|
30
August 2000
|
Mr
Maximino Carpio García, Spokesman
|
29
January 1997
|
Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero, Spokesman
|
12
April 2002
|
Mr
Gonzalo Hinojosa Fernández de Angulo, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
All
the members of the Audit and Control Committee are non executive Directors.
Moreover, according to the most recent international recommendations in this
matter, all the members of this Committee have financial training, specifically,
its Chairman has ample professional experience in financial and accounting
matters. The General Vice-Secretary and Vice-Secretary to the Board of
Directors, Mr Ramiro Sánchez de Lerín, is the acting Secretary of
this Committee.
As
to the object and duties of this Committee, one must mention that the Board of
Directors of the Company, in fulfilment of the obligation established by
“Act 44/2002, of 22nd November, on Measures to Reform the Financial
System” – additional provision eighteen -, submitted introduction of
a new article 31 bis to the Articles of Association for approval by the Ordinary
General Shareholders’ Meeting held on 11th April 2003, that grants
statutory rank to that Committee and regulates its composition and minimum
competencies, pursuant to the new legal requisites. That Ordinary General
Shareholders’ Meeting approved that amendment to the Articles of
Association with sufficient majority of capital.
The
Audit and Control Committee has a fundamental role in supervising the process of
preparation and reporting of the Company’s financial information, acting
as the controller and co-ordinator of the different players involved in them. In
that sense, its work is aimed at four fundamental matters:
(i) To
know the process of financial information and evaluate the system for accounting
verification of the Company,
(ii) To
safeguard the independence of the External Auditor, supervising its work and
providing a channel for communication between the Board of Directors and
External Auditor, between it and the management team of the Company.
(iii) To
supervise the internal audit services and
(iv) To
supervise the adequacy and integrity of the internal control systems for
financial information.
According
to what is provided in said article 31 bis of the Articles of Association, the
Audit and Control Committee must meet at least once a quarter and as often as
appropriate, when called by the Chairman, at his own decision, or when requested
by two of its members or the Executive Committee. The Audit and Control
Committee is validly constituted by direct attendance, or representation of at
least half its members, and it passes its resolutions by majority of those
present. In the event of a draw, the Chairman shall cast the deciding vote.
However, in order to hold a
greater number of meetings, the Audit and Control Committee resolved, for
financial year 2003, to meet at least ten times a year, to which end it prepared
a schedule of meetings, arranging to meet on the Friday prior to the week when
the Board of Directors of Telefónica meets. That Committee has also met
when the circumstances and matters to be dealt with have so required. Thus,
during financial year 2003, the Audit and Control Committee held thirteen
meetings.
The
meetings were held according to the pre-established Agenda and sent to the
members of the Committee in advance, along with the calling to each meeting. The
deliberations by that Committee and the resolutions and decisions passed by it
are documented in the minutes of each meeting.
These
meetings were regularly attended by the partner responsible for the
Telefónica’s Accounts Auditor to explain and clarify, at the
requirement of the Committee, aspects of the audit report and the work performed
by the External Auditor. Moreover, at the requirement of the Committee, other
members of the management team of the Company and its subsidiaries have
participated to explain specific matters that affect their respective areas of
competency. Specifically, participation by those responsible for the financial
area and accounting consolidation as well as those responsible for internal
audit is emphasised. The members of the Committee held separate meetings with
each of the contacts when this was considered necessary.
To
better perform its duties, and just as expressly set forth in the Regulations of
the Board, the Auditing and Control Committee may obtain the advice of external
experts. The Committee has not made direct use of this right, although it has
dedicated some of its meetings to analyse specific matters that required more
in-depth knowledge, which were presented by experts at the Company or by the
External Auditor.
On
the other hand, the Audit and Control Committee dedicated a monographic session
in the month of July to review its own operation and activity, taking the
aforementioned legislative novelties into account. Due to that meeting, the
Audit and Control Committee approved an annual plan of activities, in which the
main matters that must be dealt with by this Committee were dealt with during
each financial year, in relation to the following matters: (i) External Auditor,
(ii) examination of the integrity of the Financial Statements, (iii) internal
auditing and control systems, and (iv) intra-group relations.
Specifically,
as to the work carried out by this Committee during financial year 2003, the
following matters are emphasised:
(i)
In matters of financial – accounting information
§ As
to the Annual Accounts and the Management Report, the Audit and Control
Committee analysed and debated the most relevant aspects at the end of financial
year 2002, with special attention to the accounting of the main operations
performed during that financial year.
§ This
Committee has also been informed, prior to their public disclosure, on the
quarterly and semester results of the Company.
(ii) In relation to the External Auditor
§ The
Committee analysed the proposal of appointment of the Accounts Auditor to
Telefónica and its consolidated Group of companies, later raising that
proposal to the Board of Directors, in order for it propose its appointment to
the Ordinary General Shareholders’ Meeting.
§ In
one of the meetings of this Committee, the External Auditor provided a report on
the relations between it and the Telefónica Group, as well as its view of
the actual duties of the External Auditor in keeping with the legislative
changes that had taken place up to date.
§ On
the other hand, after publication of the regulations implementing the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act in matters of External Auditor independence, the Committee
considered its obligations in the matter and ordered the procedures to engage
the External Auditor to the Group to provide any kind of permitted service.
Thus, the Committee has approved, after analysis and justification, the
provision by the Accounts Auditor to the Company of certain non-audit
services.
§ The
Committee approved the fees of the External Auditor, in relation to the actual
work auditing the annual accounts, as well as to perform audit related or other
kind of services.
(iii)
In relation to internal control and internal audit and intervention
matters.
§ The
Committee has been informed in detail of the actions carried out by the internal
audit and intervention units of the Group.
§ The
Committee has analysed the risk map of the Group and its control model, and it
has been informed of the evaluations made from the internal audit services on
the operation of the systems aiming at controlling the information reported by
the Company to the markets, and on the financial-accounting information control
systems.
§ Likewise,
in the first session of the year, the internal audit services presented their
annual plan, and in October the Committee considered the proposal for
orientation of the work by the internal auditor for financial year 2004.
Moreover, the Committee was informed in several different sessions of specific
situations related to the work performed by these services.
(iv)
Other matters of interest analysed by the Audit and Control
Committee.
§ Analysis
of the most relevant legislative and regulatory novelties that may affect the
Company, either
Spanish[2]
or foreign, with special attention in the latter case to the regulations
published by the SEC implementing the Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
§ Presentation
and information on the “Audit Committees Information System”
(e-SICA) – a computer system through which the members of the Committee
are kept permanently up to date with the work being performed by the Audit and
Control units without detracting from the confidentiality of the information
– and the “System for self-evaluation of internal control”
– a system that aims to provide a measure of the internal control of all
the companies of the Telefónica Group, by the managers filling out
questionnaires adapted specifically to the Group.
§ Analysis
of the present situation of the new International Financial Reporting Standards
(IFRS).
§ Presentation
on Computer Auditing: evolution of the activity and plans for financial year
2004.
3.2.4.2 Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee.
On
the date of this Report, the composition of the Nominating, Compensation and
Corporate Governance Committee was as follows:
Members
|
Date
of appointment
|
|
Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero, Chairman
|
30
May 2001
|
Mr
Maximino Carpio García, Spokesman
|
30
August 2000
|
Mr
Pablo Isla Alvarez de Tejera, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga, Spokesman
|
27
February 2002
|
All
the members of this Committee are external or non executive Directors. The
Secretary General and of the Board, Mr Antonio Alonso Ureba, acts as
Co-ordinator of this Committee.
The
main duties of this Committee are, among others, the following:
(1) To
report on the proposals for appointment of the Company Directors and executive
officers; on the members of the Executive Committee and other Committees of the
Board of Directors, as well as the organisational structure of the Company;
(2) To
determine the Executive Chairman remuneration regime and, if appropriate, that
of the Managing Director; to set the Directors remuneration regime and review
them periodically to ensure their adequacy for the duties they perform, as well
as to report on the variable remuneration of the top management;
(3) To
report on the incentive plans;
(4) To
prepare the Annual Report on Corporate Governance.
The
Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee set up a schedule of
meetings for 2003 that allowed organisation of the tasks and responsibilities it
has been entrusted, it usually holding a monthly meeting in the days prior to
that of the Board of Directors.
Ten
meetings were held during 2003. Prior to holding the meeting, the Directors who
are members of it are convened and sent the agenda foreseen in advance, as well
as the documentation related to each of the points on that agenda, for review
and analysis by the Directors on the Committee.
The
Co-ordinator of the Meeting, Mr Antonio Alonso Ureba, General Secretary and
Secretary to the Board, takes the minutes of each one of the meetings and keeps
the relevant
documentation.
Throughout
financial year 2003, the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance
Committee has had knowledge and has reported, favourably in all cases, for later
approval by the Board of Directors or by the Executive Committee, on all Top
Management appointments and changes in the structure of the organisation that
have taken place at Telefónica, as well as any of the subsidiary
companies, as well as appointment of the new members of the Board of Directors
of subsidiaries, for later approval by the Board of Directors of the relevant
company. To perform that task, the Committee has examined the statutory report
on the post to be covered, issued by Human Resources, the Curriculum and profile
of the candidate, for adequate assessment of the office and the person
proposed.
Likewise,
throughout 2003, the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee
reported that there were no conflicts of interest in relation to members of the
Board of Directors or Top Management of the Company and it has supervised that
the different operations performed with significant shareholders BBVA and La
Caixa, have been performed under market conditions and have respected the
principle of parity in treatment of the shareholders.
At
the request of the Chairman of Telefónica, in the first quarter of the
year, the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee reported
on the Top Management bonuses for financial year 2002, and in 2003 a significant
reduction was applied in relation to the economic results of the Group, that had
an especial effect on the Chairman and Managing Director.
As a
duty of that Committee, the Stock Option schemes of the different companies in
the group were examined, concentrating analysis of these on the problems of
their application in relation to some of the parties who benefit from them.
Likewise,
in fulfilment of one of the main recommendations of Corporate Governance, an
evaluation of the Directors’ compensation for financial year 2003 has been
undertaken, according to the terms set forth in article 28 of the Articles of
Association, and collaboration has been requested, as in preceding years, by a
specialised external consultant, to prepare a report on the listed companies
Board
members compensation
..
Throughout
financial year 2003, modifications have been presented on two occasions in the
Organisational Structure of the Telefónica Group by the Chairman of the
Company, proceeding to study, analyse this and issue the favourable report
required by the Regulations of the
Board.
In
fulfilment of its basic responsibility, throughout 2003, this Committee has
reported on the appointment by co-option of a Board of Directors member and on
the creation of a new Board of Directors sub-committee, the International
Affairs Committee.
Nominating,
Compensation and Corporate
Governance
Committee provided a favourable report on the Regulations on Communication of
Information to the Markets, prepared due to the need to comply with the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act, and according to the commitment acquired by the Board of
Directors at the last General Shareholders’ Meeting to adopt the best
corporate governance practices.
In
order to comply with the Transparency Act for listed companies, the
Nominating, Compensation and Corporate
Governance
Committee supervised commencement of the work to prepare the Regulations of the
General Shareholders’ Meeting and undertook the work to adapt the
Regulations of the Board to the Transparency Act.
Finally,
to continue the work undertaken last financial year 2002, it continued the task
of examining the situation of the Group considering the recommendations of the
different Corporate Governance Codes, the draft of this Corporate Governance
Report being presented and reviewed by this Committee several times.
3.2.4.3 Human Resources and Corporate Reputation Committee.
On
the date of this Report, the composition of the Human Resources and Corporate
Reputation Committee is as follows:
Members
|
Date of
appointment
|
|
Mr
Pablo Isla Alvarez de Tejera, Chairman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla, Spokesman
|
22
July 1998
|
Mr
Enrique Used Aznar, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
All
the members of this Committee are external or non executive Directors.
Notwithstanding
others it may be attributed by the Board of Directors, this Committee has the
main duties, on one hand and in matters of Human Resources, of analysing,
reporting and proposing that the Board pass the appropriate resolutions on
matters of Company personnel policy; and on the other, in matters of Corporate
Reputation, to encourage progress on the Corporate Reputation Project of the
Telefónica Group and implementation of its central values, to which end
the relevant instruments and tools shall be provided within organisation of the
Group.
During
2003, the Human Resources and Corporate Reputation Committee held four meetings.
The meetings were held according to the Agenda previously set and sent to the
members along with the calling of each meeting. At all the meetings, the
different matters submitted for deliberation and, if appropriate, decision, were
discussed in due depth, with active intervention by all the members in the
different debates. The deliberations of the Committee, the resolutions and
decisions made by it, are recorded in the minutes of each meeting, prepared by
the Secretary, Ms Consuelo Barbé Capdevila, Under-Director General of the
Corporate Department, and later distributed among the members for their approval
and remarks. It is then submitted for approval, as point one of the Agenda, of
the next meeting of the Committee that is held.
The
meetings of this Committee are usually attended by members of the management
team responsible for the corporate areas of Human Resources and Corporate
Reputation.
During
2003, this Committee examined, debated and analysed the following main matters:
(i)
In matters of Human Resources:
§ The
Committee was informed about the situation of the staff at Telefónica de
España, S.A.U. and as to alternatives to following in relations with it,
as well as the situation of the Collaborating Company system in matters of
health assistance.
§ Presentation
of a new model of variable remuneration of the Telefónica Group and
analysis of the situation of the matters in course on human resources, in all
the lines of activity of the Telefónica Group.
§ Specifically,
those responsible for Human Resources of the main lines of business of
Telefónica, -Telefónica de España, Telefónica
Móviles and Telefónica Internacional-, presented the Management
Report on Human Resources in each one of those lines to the Committee at a
monographic session held on 23rd June 2003.
(ii)
In relation to Corporate Reputation matters:
§ The
Committee was presented the Memorandum on Corporate Reputation and the statement
of the activities carried out in matters of corporate reputation during 2002,
and those foreseen for 2003.
§ The
“Monitoring Report on Corporate Reputation” was presented to the
Committee, detailing the lines of work established to improve the corporate
reputation within the Telefónica Group in aspects in which it is
considered that these must be reinforced.
3.2.4.4 Regulation Committee.
On
the date of this report, the composition of the Regulation Committee is as
follows:
Members
|
Date of
appointment
|
|
Mr
Enrique Used Aznar, Chairman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
Antonio Alonso Ureba, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
This
Committee is formed by two external or non executive Directors and by an
executive Director.
The
main objectives of the Regulation Committee are the permanent monitoring of the
main matters of regulatory order that affect the Telefónica Group at each
moment and to provide a channel for communication and information between the
management team and the Board of Directors in regulatory matters.
The meetings of the Regulation
Committee are generally held monthly, except when its Chairman decides not to
convene it as no event of especial relevance that need be debated by the
Committee has arisen during the period. There is an annual schedule of meetings
that is approved at the last meeting of the year immediately preceding. During
2003, the Committee met on eight occasions.
The
meetings were held according to a pre-established Agenda and sent to the
Committee members in advance, along with the calling for each meeting. The
deliberations by this Committee and the resolutions passed by it are recorded in
the minutes of each meeting.
The
meetings of this Committee are usually attended by Mr Luis Lada Díaz,
General Manager of Development, Planning and Regulation, and Mr Javier de la
Pinta García, Sub-director General of Corporate Regulation, as well as
the Vice-Secretary General and of the Board of Telefónica, Mr Ramiro
Sánchez de Lerín, who also acts as Secretary to it, and the
Director of the Legal Department of Telecommunications, Ms María Victoria
Cerezo Rodríguez-Sedano. Her essential function is to support the
Chairman of the Committee in more complex regulatory matters, or those requiring
technical knowledge of the matter.
During financial year 2003, the
Regulation Committee analysed and debated the most relevant regulatory matters,
to which end the corporate regulatory and juridical departments prepare a
general document on the regulatory situation of the Telefónica Group,
that is updated at each meeting. Moreover, when the matter required, those
responsible for regulation and executives of the different Telefónica
business Lines were invited to provide a detailed presentation of the regulatory
problems in their businesses.
Among the most relevant regulatory
matters subject to analysis by the Committee during financial year 2003 one may
point out the following:
(i)
Analysis of the regulatory situation in
Spain: the process of development of the
General Telecommunications Act and relevant Regulations, the actions of the
Telecommunications Market Committee (CMT) that affect the Telefónica
Group and the files open at different Companies, the situation of tariff
re-balance at Telefónica de España, the undertakings acquired by
Telefónica to develop the cable network, development of the wide band
services in Spain, setting the new framework of tariffs and prices of
Telefónica de España in the year 2004, and flexibility of the
financial commitments linked to the UMTS third generation mobile telephony
licence.
(ii)
Analysis of the regulatory situation in Latin
America: the
process has been followed to update the tariff framework in Argentina, and claim
measures against the Republic of Argentina. The situation that has arisen in
Peru due to the proposal to eliminate the basic rental has been analysed at
several meetings, and the Committee was informed on the impact on revenue and
the actions taken. Likewise, specific monitoring has taken place at several
meetings of the claim of unconstitutionality concerning the concession contract
with Telefónica del Perú (TdP) that finally was not successful,
and the Committee was informed of the proceedings to request an extension to the
concession agreement. The process of renegotiation of the concession agreement
with Telesp and the issues related to the tariff readjustment in fixed telephony
were the most relevant matters dealt with by the Committee in relation to
Brazil. As to Chile, the Committee has monitored the process of negotiation of
the new tariff framework for 2004-2009.
(iii)
Analysis of the regulatory situation in
Europe: The
Committee was also informed of the possible impact in Spain of the European
Recommendation on relevant markets and the draft of Recommendation on Remedies
prepared jointly by the European Committee and the European Group of National
Regulators, as well as the activities performed by Telefónica along with
other operators and major companies in the European sector in the
“Brussels Round Table” initiative.
In
2003, the Regulation Committee commissioned diverse studies by consultancy firms
and external legal advisors, related to specific matters of special impact for
the Company, related to tariff re-balance of Telefónica de España
and in relation to the new General Telecommunications Act.
3.2.4.5 Service Quality and Customer Service Committee.
As
of the date of this Report, the composition of the Service Quality and Customer
Service Committee is as follows:
Members
|
Date of
appointment
|
|
Mr
Gonzalo Hinojosa Fernández de Angulo, Chairman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
Carlos Colomer Casellas, Spokesman
|
26
June 2002
|
Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla, Spokesman
|
26
March 1999
|
All
the members of this Committee are external or non executive Directors.
The
Service Quality and Customer Service Committee has the fundamental mission of
study and monitoring the quality levels of the main services provided by the
companies in the Telefónica Group, as well as the standards of customer
service.
In
order for this Committee to know and be able to analyse the fulfilment of the
goals set, its Chairman commissioned a summary of the variables-objectives for
each business line in the Telefónica Group for the year 2003. Moreover, a
working method has been provided that allows a quarterly report on each line of
activity, related to the evolution of its objectives, based on quality
indicators and ratios set for each on of its businesses.
This
Committee has met six times during 2003. The meetings follow a fixed agenda,
that is sent along with the relevant documentation, approximately fifteen days
before the date of the meeting. At each session, the Secretary to the Committee,
Ms Marta Turégano Martínez, Director of litigation Matters, takes
the relevant minutes. The meetings of the Committee have been attended by
diverse representatives of the different lines of activity.
The
main matters analysed during 2003 were as follows:
§ Analysis of
the management charts sent by the different lines of business, based on the
indicators used for the quality monitoring, in order to set objectives for 2003
and to show the results obtained the previous year for to maintain at least the
quality levels.
§ Presentation
of the Quality Plan for Latin America, called T-Latam Regional Plan, aimed
fundamentally at setting global objectives to allow effective quality monitoring
and perceived within the management organisation of the regional area.
§ Presentation
of the satisfaction study project of the Telefónica Group, that has the
fundamental objective of evaluating the risk of customer loss and its reasons,
as well as the priorities of the Group when dealing with policies aimed at
customer loyalty, considering the variety of countries in which the Group
operates.
§ Analysis of
the model proposed by the marketing area for correct evaluation of the level of
satisfaction generated by the commercial brands of the Telefónica Group
and their effects on the perception and evaluation of the Group.
3.2.4.6 International Affairs Committee.
The
International Affairs Committee was created by the Board of Directors on 26th
February 2003 and formally constituted by a resolution of the Board of Directors
on 28th May 2003. As of the date of this Report, the composition of this
Committee isas follows:
Members
|
Date of
appointment
|
|
Mr
Fernando de Almansa Moreno-Barreda, Chairman
|
28
May 2003
|
Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero, Spokesman
|
28
May 2003
|
Mr
Luis Lada Díaz, Spokesman
|
28
May 2003
|
Mr
Enrique Used Aznar, Spokesman
|
28
May 2003
|
Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga, Spokesman
|
28
May 2003
|
All
the members of this Committee are external or non executive Directors, except
for one, who is an executive Director.
During
financial year 2003, this Committee held two meetings. The meetings follow a
fixed agenda, which is sent with the relevant documentation approximately three
days before the date of the meeting. At each meeting, the Secretary to the
Committee, Ms Marta Turégano Martínez, Director of litigation
Matters, takes the relevant minutes. Diverse representative of the different
lines of activity have attended the meetings of the Committee.
This
Committee has the fundamental mission of analysing the international matters
that are relevant to the Telefónica Group, reporting these to the Board
of Directors when appropriate. In this sense, the Committee pays special
attention to institutional relations with the countries in which companies in
the Telefónica Group operate, to the company’s competitive
position, to strategy and corporate image matters, and to the agenda and
performance of the Company Foundations in such countries.
During
2003, the International Affairs Committee analysed, among others, the following
matters:
§ Examination
of the general political-institutional situation in Latin America, with special
reference to the social, political and economic situation in the countries where
Telefónica operates.
§ Analysis of
the objectives established by Telefónica Móviles in each one of
the countries in which the Company is present, and its position in relation to
competitors.
§ Review of
the state of the Institutional Relations Plan project prepared in order to
develop the presence of Telefónica in International organisations and
Forums. The Committee emphasises the importance of this plan and of the creation
of a corporate culture in the countries in which the Company operates, as well
as in the different international organisations and forums.
3.3 REMUNERATION OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEMBERS.
The
remuneration of the Directors of Telefónica consists of a fixed monthly
allowance and per diems for attending the meetings of the Board sub-committees.
Executive Directors may also receive the relevant fees for performing their
executive duties.
Their
regulation is set forth in article 28 of the Articles of Association, that
indicate that the sum of the remuneration to be paid by the Company to the Board
of Directors is set by the General Shareholders’ Meeting, it being the
actual Board of Directors which later distributes that sum among the different
Directors. In that sense, the General Shareholders’ Meeting held on 11th
April 2003, set the annual maximum gross sum of remuneration to be received by
the Board of Directors at 6 million euros, for fixed assignment and per diems
for attending the meetings of the Board sub-committees. In that sense, we may
point out that, in line with the best practices in this field, remuneration of
the Directors is linked to results.
The
total amount of remuneration received by the Directors of Telefónica
during financial year 2003 amounted to 10,900,943.98 euros: 3,339,958.34 euros
by fixed assignment, including the remuneration received for belonging to the
Board of Directors of other companies in the Telefónica Group; 120,247.86
euros in per diems for attending the meetings of the Board sub-committees,
including per diems for attending the sub-committees of Boards of Directors of
other companies in the Telefónica Group: 7,275,864.86 euros in wages and
variable remuneration of the executive Directors; 114,872.92 euros in
remuneration in kind in favour of executive Directors, that include life
insurance premiums; and 50,000 euros in contributions by the Company, as
promoter, and in favour of the executive Directors, to pension schemes.
The
following tables detail the compensation and sums received by the Directors of
Telefónica in that year:
Board of Directors. Annual amount of the set allowance
received by each Director (in euros)
OFFICES
|
2003
|
Chairman
|
90,151.92
|
Vice-Chairmen
|
150,253.02
|
Executive
Proprietary
Independent
|
90,151.92 90,151.92 90,151.92
|
Executive Committee .
Annual amount of the fixed assignment received by each Director (in euros):
OFFICES
|
2003
|
Chairman
|
60,101.19
|
Vice-Chairman
|
60,101.19
|
members
|
60,101.19
|
The
Directors do not receive any per diems for attending the meetings of the Board
of Directors and the Executive Committee.
Other
Board sub-committees. Annual amount of the
per diems paid during financial year 2003 for attending the meetings of the
Board sub-committees, received by the Directors overall:
BOARD-SUBCOMMITTEES
|
2003
|
Audit
and Control
|
Per
diem for meeting: 858.61 euros
No.
of meetings paid: 9
Total
received: 26,616.91
|
Nominating,
Compensation and Corporate Governance
|
Per
diem for meeting: 858.61 euros
No.
of meetings paid: 6
Total
received: 24,899.69
|
Human
Resources and Corporate Reputation
|
Per
diem for meeting: 858.61 euros
No.
of meetings paid: 6
Total
received: 20,606.64
|
Regulation
|
Per
diem for meeting: 858.61 euros
No.
of meetings paid: 5
Total
received: 12,879.15
|
Service
Quality and Commercial Care
|
Per
diem for meeting: 858.61 euros
No.
of meetings paid: 4
Total
received: 8,586.1
|
International
Affairs
|
Per
diem for meeting: 858.61 euros
No.
of meetings paid: 2
Total
received: 7,727.49
|
Executive
Directors. Total amounts received by the
set of executive Directors for each one of the following matters (in
euros).
ITEMS
|
2003
|
Wages
|
3,811,030.07
|
Variable
remuneration
|
3,464,834.79
|
Remuneration
in kind
|
114,872.92
|
Contributions
to pension schemes
|
50,000
|
The
executive Directors Mr César Alierta Izuel, Mr Fernando Abril-Martorell
Hernández (who presented his resignation from the position of Managing
Director of the Company on 24th September 2003), Mr Antonio J. Alonso Ureba, and
Mr Luis Lada Díaz, acting as directors of the Telefónica Group,
were the beneficiaries of a remuneration scheme linked to the listed value of
the Telefónica share, for the directors of the Group, called “Plan
TOP”, the term of which ended during financial year 2003, without them
exercising their options to Telefónica shares that were the object of
that scheme, so those options were extinguished and became void. The cost to
Telefónica of that remuneration scheme during financial year 2003, as to
the Executive Directors participating in it, amounted to 1.02 million
euros.
Moreover,
one must point out that during 2003 the non executive Directors did not receive
any remuneration whatsoever in pensions or life insurance, nor did they
participate in remuneration schemes linked to the listed value of the shares.
Lastly,
the Company does not grant, nor has it granted during 2003, any advances, loans
or credits whatsoever to the Directors, nor to any of its main executives, in
fulfilment of the requisites of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act published in the United
States, which is applicable to Telefónica as a company listed on that
market.
3.4 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
3.4.1 Directors appointed in relation to Significant Shareholders.
Just
as stated in section 2.1 of this Report, certain members of the Board of
Directors have been appointed in relation to the significant shareholders.
Thus,
the following directors have been appointed in relation to BBVA:
- Mr
Jesús María Cadenato Matía
- Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero
- Mr
José Fonollosa García
- Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga
Moreover,
in relation to La Caixa, the following Directors have been
appointed:
- Mr
Isidro Fainé Casas
- Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla
All
the Directors mentioned have or have had a labour or mercantile relation with
the companies in relation to which they have been appointed members of the Board
of Directors of Telefónica. Thus, the offices held by each of these
persons in those companies are detailed below:
- Mr
Jesús María Cadenato Matía is the Major Industrial
Corporations Manager at BBVA.
- Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero is a former Managing Director of
BBVA, now in early retirement.
- Mr
José Fonollosa García is a former Managing Director of BBVA, now
in early retirement.
- Mr
Gregorio Villalabeitia Galarraga is a former Managing Director of BBVA, now in
early retirement.
- Mr
Isidro Fainé Casas is the Managing Director of La Caixa.
- Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla is Assistant Executive Managing Director of La
Caixa.
On
the other hand, we must point out that none of the members of the Board of
Directors of Telefónica is, in turn, a member of the Board of Directors
of either of these two companies. However, one must point out that
Telefónica has knowledge of the fact that Mr José Antonio
Fernández Rivero has been appointed to the Board of Directors of BBVA at
the General Shareholders’ Meeting of that company held on 28th
February.
3.4.2 Members of the Board of Directors of Telefónica with management or executive offices in other companies in the Group.
The
following are identified as members of the Board of Directors of
Telefónica who have management or executive offices in other companies in
the Group, specifying those offices in each case:
- Mr
Fernando de Almansa Moreno-Barreda is a member of the Boards of Directors of the
following companies in the Group: Telefónica Móviles, S.A.,
Telefónica del Perú, S.A.A, Telecomunicaciones de Sao Paulo, S.A.
(Telesp), and Telefónica de Argentina, S.A.
- Mr
Jesús María Cadenato Matía is a member of the Board of
Directors of Uno-e Bank, S.A.
- Mr
Maximino Carpio García is a member of the Board of Directors of
Telefónica Móviles, S.A.
- Mr
José Antonio Fernández Rivero is Chairman of Adquira
España, S.A.
- Mr
Alfonso Ferrari Herrero is a member of the Board of Directors of
Compañía de Telecomunicaciones de Chile, S.A. and
Telefónica del Perú, S.A.A.
- Mr
Miguel Horta e Costa is a member of the Board of Directors of Telesp Celular
Participaçoes, S.A.
- Mr
Luis Lada Díaz is a member of the Board of Directors of Telefónica
Móviles, S.A. and Sogecable, S.A.
- Mr
Antonio Massanell Lavilla is a member of the Board of Directors of
Telefónica Móviles, S.A.
- Mr
Enrique Used Aznar is a member of the Board of Directors of Terra Networks,
S.A., Telecomunicaciones de Sao Paulo, S.A. (Telesp) and de Telefónica
del Perú, S.A.A.
- Mr
Mario Eduardo Vázquez is Chairman Executive de Telefónica de
Argentina, S.A. He is also Chairman of the following companies in the Group:
Telefónica Móviles Argentina, S.A., Telefónica
Comunicaciones Personales, S.A., Radio Móvil Digital Argentina, S.A.,
Radio Servicios, S.A., Telinver, S.A., Atento Argentina, S.A., Katalyx
Argentina, S.A., Adquira Argentina, S.A., and Fundación
Telefónica; he is also Vice-Chairman of the following companies:
Telefónica Holding de Argentina S.A., Compañía
Internacional de Telecomunicaciones S.A. Lastly, he is the Managing Director of
the following companies in the Group: Katalyx Food Service Argentina S.R.L.,
Katalyx Cataloguing Argentina S.R.L., Katalyx Construction Argentina S.R.L.,
Katalyx Transportation Argentina S.R.L.
- Mr
Antonio Viana-Baptista is Executive Chairman of Telefónica
Móviles, S.A. He is also a Director of the following companies:
Telefónica Móviles España, S.A., Terra Networks, S.A., on
behalf of Telefónica DataCorp, Brasilcel, N.V, Tele Sudeste Celular
Participaçoes, S.A. and Telesp Celular Participaçoes,
S.A.
4
INFORMATION ON RELATED TRANSACTIONS
AND INTRAGROUP OPERATIONS
4.1 OPERATIONS PERFORMED WITH SIGNIFICANT SHAREHOLDERS.
As
to operations with significant shareholders, the Company has established control
measures set forth under the Regulations of the Board of Directors, so it
formally reserves knowledge and authorisation of any transaction between the
Company and any of its significant shareholders, as well as following a report
by the Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee to analyse
and evaluate the operation from the point of view of parity in treatment of the
shareholders and the market conditions of the same. Moreover, the Directors
related to those shareholders are obliged to abstain from the deliberation of
those matters.
The
two shareholders of Significant Stakes in the stock capital of Telefónica
are financial institutions. According to this, the Company has performed
operations with both companies within their ordinary activity, and always on
market conditions. Thus, during financial year 2003, the types of operations
performed were as follows:
(a) As to the usual treasury transactions:
§ Formalisation/renewal
of financing lines.
§ Formalisation
of renting lines.
§ Formalisation
of factoring lines.
§ Formalisation
of banking services agreements: collection and payment of commercial and
financial nature, administration and custody of bank guarantees, custody of
securities, credit cards, etc.
§ Temporary
Financial Investments, to place treasury surplus.
§ Sale
of promissory notes of the company according to the Telefónica Promissory
Notes Issue Programme.
(b) As to capital markets transactions:
§ Formalisation
of bonds or any other debt instrument under any debt programme by
Telefónica.
§ Formalisation
of operations with convertible or exchangeable bonds, own shares, shares of
companies in the Group and financial stakes.
§ Formalisation
of syndicated loans.
§ Formalisation
of guarantees.
§ Formalisation
of derivative operations on interest rates, exchange rates, political risk or
credit risk.
§ Intermediation
operations in stock exchange operations.
During
financial year 2003, apart from operations aforementioned, the relevant
operations by the Company performed with any of its significant shareholders,
were as follows:
Restructuring
of the debt of Telefónica Data Colombia with BBVA Banco
Ganadero
The
Board of Directors of Telefónica – following a favourable report of
its Nominating, Compensation and Corporate Governance Committee -, resolved on
29th January 2003, to approve the restructuring of the debt that
Telefónica Data Colombia had with the Colombian institution BBVA Banco
Ganadero, amounting to 26.051 million Colombian pesos (approximately 9 million
euros), by novation of part of the loans granted by that Bank (amounting to
approximately half that debt) and capitalisation of an amount approximately
equivalent to 4.5 million euros, that involved subscription by the said creditor
Bank of shares representing 35% of the stock capital of Telefónica Data
Colombia.
Loan
by BBVA to Telefónica Data Colombia
As
resolved by the Board of Directors of Telefónica on 30th April 2003
– passed following a favourable report of its Nominating, Compensation and
Corporate Governance Committee -, Telefónica Data Colombia was authorised
to apply for and obtain a loan from BBVA of the sum of 5 million US dollars.
Appointment
of Agent Entities to distribute the shares of Antena
3
On
24th September 2003, following a favourable report of the
Nominating, Compensation and Corporate
Governance
Committee, the Board of Directors of Telefónica approved the hiring of
BBVA and La Caixa to act as Agent Entities to distribute the shares of Antena 3
de Televisión, S.A. among the shareholders of
Telefónica.
4.2 OPERATIONS PERFORMED WITH THE DIRECTORS AND EXECUTIVES OF THE COMPANY AND OF THE GROUP.
According
to the information provided by the Company, no member of its Board of Directors, nor any executive[4]of the Company, has performed operations with the Company in the course of the
last financial year.
In
this sense, one must point out that, according to the terms established in the
Regulations of the Board, the Directors must abstain from intervening in
deliberations that affect matters in which they have a direct or indirect
interest, or when they affect a member of their family or a company in which
they have an executive office, or hold a significant stake in its share capital.
Likewise, the Director may not directly or indirectly perform professional or
commercial transactions with Telefónica, or with any of the companies in
the Group, unless the Board of Directors, with the abstention of the Director
affected, approves the transaction with the favourable vote of at least 90% of
the Directors present, and following a report by the
Nominating, Compensation and Corporate
Governance
Committee.
Moreover,
one must state that, as established in the Internal Code of Conduct for
Securities Markets Issues of Telefónica, the Company directors are
obliged to (a) act at all times with loyalty to the Group and to its
shareholders, regardless of their own interests or those of others; (b) to
abstain from intervening in or influencing any decision making that may affect
the persons or entities with which conflict exists; and (c) to abstain from
accessing information classified as confidential that affects that conflict.
Moreover, these persons are under the obligation to inform the Regulatory
Compliance Unit of the Company of such situations that may potentially lead to
any conflict of interests.
4.3 SIGNIFICANT OPERATIONS PERFORMED WITH OTHER COMPANIES BELONGING TO THE SAME GROUP.
Telefónica
is the parent company that heads a Group of companies that perform their
corporate object through their stake in these companies. According to the
organisational structure of the Group and its co-ordination policies, one must
point out that, among others, its financial policy and, in some cases, the
actual financial management is centralised through that parent company.
According to this, most of the operations performed by the Company with the
companies belonging to its Group are operations of a financial nature, to cover
their needs for funds and coverage of interest rate and exchange rate risks.
According to this, as to financial
year 2003, as recorded in the individual Annual Accounts of Telefónica
ended on
31st December 2003, the total credits to companies in the Group amounted to 23,719.81
million euros, while the debt with companies in the Group and associates
amounted to 25,512.67 million euros.
As
to the balances with associated companies, one must point out that on
31st December 2003, the financing
provided to Sogecable, S.A. according to the commitments acquired in the
agreements signed in relation to integration of the satellite platforms, the
headings “Other credits” long term and “Credits to associated
companies” short term on the Consolidated Balance sheet at
31st December 2003, include an
amount of 222.49 and 9.27 million euros, respectively, with that company.
Moreover, one must point out a long term balance of 64.65 million euros with
Medi Telecom and a short term balance with Ipse 2000, amounting to 280.58
million euros.
Likewise, attention is drawn to the headings “Debtor
associated companies” and “Debts to associated companies”
amounting to 48.18 and 26.74 million euros, respectively, for the companies in
the Group Brasilcel. In relation to Medi Telecom, these sums amounted to 9.33
and 4.21 million euros in each heading.
On the other hand, the amount
of sales and services rendered that are recorded in the Profit and Loss Account
for the financial year ended on 31st December 2003, are for sales to companies in the Group, mainly the management
contract with Telefónica de Argentina, S.A In that sense, in November
1990, Telefónica and Telefónica de Argentina, S.A. entered into a
management agreement in force until 2003, which regulated the advisory services
provided by Telefónica and the price of these. The revenue received for
that item during financial year 2003 amounted to 28.02 million euros.
Apart
from these operations of an ordinary nature, the 2003 Strategic Alliance between
Telefónica and Terra Networks, S.A. must be mentioned, as described in
the relevant information on the decisions made by the Board of Directors in
section 3.2.2 of this Report.
5
INFORMATION ON RISK CONTROL SYSTEMS
5.1 GENERAL MODEL OF THE RISK CONTROL SYSTEM.
Telefónica
performs permanent monitoring of the most significant risks of the main
companies forming its Group. To do so, the Company has a map recording the risks
requiring specific control and monitoring according to their importance. With
the same objective of permanent monitoring of the risks identified, in November
2001, Telefónica set up a project aimed at protecting one of the most
important assets of the Company: its reputation. To do so, it identified the
main risks to the reputation of the Company before its customers, shareholders
and investors, employees, suppliers, partners, the media and society at large.
Identification of these risks and
processes is performed by the Directorate General of Internal Audit and
Management Resources, which is responsible for the Internal Audit department of
the Company, and its results are reported periodically to the Audit and Control
Committee of Telefónica.
The
50 risks considered by the model are classified in the following
categories:
(i)
Risks related to the business processes.
§ Operational
risks
§ Integrity
risks
§ management
and human resources risks
§ Technological
risks
§ Financial
risks
(ii)
Information risks.
§ Operating
information
§ Financial
information
§ Strategic
evaluation
(iii)
Risks related to the
environment.
(iv)
Corporate
reputation risks .
In
order to establish adequate control systems, Telefónica has a set of
rules, approved by the Board of Directors, that regulate the basic aspects of
this system, as well as implementation of the control systems. The main internal
regulations to these ends will be as follows:
(a) Regulation on the
registration, communication and Control of financial/accounting
information.
§ Recording,
communication and control of the financial-accounting information.
§ Disclosure
controls and procedures regulation.
§ Intra-group
operations: procedures for recording, payment and conciliation.
(b) Regulations
on control over the activities of the Company personnel.
§ Travel
and hospitality expenses of the executives: limits, justification,
reimbursement, etc.
§ Regulations
on physical safety and information.
(c) Regulations
on external representation and links to the Company.
§ Payments:
segregation of duties, concurrent double signature, bank conciliations, etc.
§ Powers
of Attorney: to sign contracts, open accounts, withdraw funds, etc.
Thus,
Telefónica has certain units with responsibilities for control over
specific risks to the Company, such as Risks and Insurance, Reputation,
Regulation, Control of Management and Human Resources (labour
risks).
Lastly,
the Company has an Intervention Unit for control of application of the funds,
control of the relevant operations, control of travel and hospitality expenses,
implementation of basic controls in the processes of greatest risk, etc.
5.2 CONTROLS OVER THE FINANCIAL-ACCOUNTING INFORMATION PROCESS.
Within
the Company risks, due to its special relevance to investors and shareholders,
one must emphasise the control system over the process of financial-accounting
information. At Telefónica, that system is regulated through the
following manuals, instructions and regulations:
§ Manual
of Rules for Evaluation and Accounting Policies.
§ Instructions
for closing and external audit.
§ Annual
calendar of financial – accounting information.
§ Corporate
Accounting Plan.
§ Manual
of the Subsidiary Information System (technical – computing instrument for
reporting financial-accounting information and to consolidate the financial
statements).
§ Rules
of intra-group and internal control operations.
In
another order of things, one must point out that all the companies in the Group
have insurance coverage for reasonable protection against the possible risks of
damage to the fixed assets assigned to the operations and possible loss of
profit arising from this. These policies include certain excesses. Management of
that insurance is centralised at Group level within the Subdirectorate General
of Corporate Risks and Insurance.
6
RELATIONS WITH SHAREHOLDERS AND MARKETS
6.1 OPERATION OF THE GENERAL SHAREHOLDERS’ MEETING.
The
General Shareholders’ Meeting is the supreme deciding body through which
the corporate will is expressed and, in that sense, the shareholders, legally
and validly constituting the General Meeting, decide by majority on the matters
that lie within the remit of the Meeting, attributed to it by Law or the
Articles of Association.
6.1.1 Existence and description of the Regulations of the General Shareholders’ Meeting.
Telefónica foresees
submission for consideration and approval, if appropriate, at its next Ordinary
General Shareholders’ Meeting, of its Regulations of the General
Shareholders’ Meeting, in which it establishes the rules and principles of
its organisation and operation, thus fulfilling the terms of Act 26/2003, of
17th July. Until this takes place, the organisation, operation and development of the
General Shareholders’ Meeting of Telefónica is governed by the
terms of the Mercantile Laws in force and the Articles of Association of the
Company.
The General
Shareholders’ Meeting of the Company is called by its Board of Directors,
which approves not only convening of the Meeting, but also the matters that are
to be submitted for deliberation and, if appropriate, resolution by the Meeting
(Agenda), as well as the Proposals of Resolutions that are submitted for its
approval, along with the reports that may be required on those Proposals in each
case.
Calling of the General
Shareholders’ Meeting, as well as its Agenda, are published for the
shareholders and public at large in the Official Journal of the Mercantile
Registry of Spain and in several national newspapers published in the city where
the Company has its registered office (Madrid, Spain). Likewise, the calling and
Agenda of the Meeting shall be announced in other newspapers that are widely
read in the foreign countries where the Company shares are listed, when the
regulatory rules there so require, and also in a financial daily that is widely
read in the financial world.
6.1.2 Rights of the shareholders in relation to the General Shareholders’ Meeting.
The
rights of each and every one of the shareholders, in relation to holding the
General Shareholders’ Meeting, are subject to thorough respect and
treatment by the Company, on the terms and conditions established in the
applicable laws in force and in the Articles of Association.
Those
rights are, apart from to impugn the corporate resolutions passed by the Meeting
pursuant to the requisites established in the Act, the right to information, the
right to attend and the right to vote.
In order to facilitate and make
possible the exercise of the right to information by any shareholder, the
proposals of resolutions to be submitted for approval of the Meeting and the
documents and mandatory reports related to them, are made available to the
shareholders on the terms and conditions established in the Spanish Companies
Act, from when the announcements to call the Meeting are published.
Likewise, the Company attends,
within the possibilities of the requests for information in relation to the
matters on the Agenda of the General Shareholders’ Meeting, formulated by
any shareholder, in the days immediately prior to holding the Meeting, as well
as on the day of the actual Meeting being held, the agenda of which expressly
includes a turn for shareholders to speak, in which all shareholders attending
the Meeting may speak and their interventions shall always be replied to by the
Chairman of the Company.
As to
the rights to attend and vote at the General Shareholders’ Meeting, the
Company facilitates exercise of such right to the greatest extent, always within
the framework provided by the applicable laws in force and the Articles of
Association, especially that of representation of the shareholders at the
General Shareholders’ Meeting, which may be granted in favour of any
person, even if not a shareholder.
Lastly,
the manifestation of respect and guarantee ensured by the Company of the rights
of the shareholders in relation to the General Shareholders’ Meeting, it
must mention, on one hand, that formation of the roll of attendance and
calculation of the
quorum
of attendance for valid constitution of the Meeting are entrusted to a firm of
recognised prestige in its sector of activity, that acts subject to accredited
professional practice; and on the other hand, that the Board of Directors
requires the presence of a Notary Public to take the Minutes of the General
Shareholders’ Meeting.
6.1.3 Data on attendance at previous General Meetings of Shareholders
In
the last three years, the General Shareholders’ Meeting of
Telefónica has held three ordinary sessions, the attendance data of which
is as follows:
Ordinary
General Shareholders’ Meeting of 15 June 2001
Shareholders present: | 907 |
Shareholders represented: | 110,936 |
TOTAL SHAREHOLDERS | 111,843 |
| |
Shares present: | 2,277,209 |
Shares represented: | 1,772,729,452 |
TOTAL SHARES | 1,775,006,661 |
| |
PERCENTAGE OF SHARE CAPITAL | 39.02% |
Ordinary General Shareholders’ Meeting of 12 April
2002
Shareholders present: | 864 |
Shareholders represented: | 121,069 |
TOTAL SHAREHOLDERS | 121,933 |
| |
Shares present: | 2,220,812 |
Shares represented: | 1,688,052,956 |
TOTAL SHARES | 1,690,273,768 |
| |
PERCENTAGE OF SHARE CAPITAL | 35.47% |
Ordinary General Shareholders’ Meeting of 11 April
2003
Shareholders present: | 1.139 |
Shareholders represented: | 115.411 |
TOTAL SHAREHOLDERS | 116.550 |
| |
Shares present: | 2.848.105 |
Shares represented: | 2.032.297.555 |
TOTAL SHARES | 2.035.145.660 |
| |
PERCENTAGE OF SHARE CAPITAL | 41.05% |
6.1.4 List of the resolutions passed by the General Shareholders’ Meeting.